This week the Pole Barn Guru answers reader questions about insulating a building that already has reflective foil radian barrier, if one needs vents or exhaust fan in the gable ends of the roof with the high heat/humidity of Alabama, and requirements for frost wall or slab for frost heave.
DEAR POLE BARN GURU: I recently moved into a house with a 40×30 pole barn (wood post and wood trusses) with a metal exterior. The building has a reflective foil radiant barrier between the metal and wood structure. It is extremely hot in the summer and cold in the winter. I want to insulate and cannot afford spray foam. I also don’t have the ability to remove the walls to remove the foil barrier that way. I do have some Silvercote insulation that has an attached vapor barrier. It is just a fiberglass roll insulation that has an attached vapor barrier to it. It is sold around here for use as insulation in metal buildings. I was given enough to insulate the whole shop from someone that had left overs. I would like to install this insulation to help with temps in the shop. I have tried to research to get an answer on the best way to go about this. The shop builder said just put it up but I feel that would create a double vapor barrier. Is my best route to cut the foil radiant barrier out and then install the fiberglass insulation with vapor barrier facing the interior of the building? This would basically take the foil barrier out and install the fiberglass against the metal with the attached face vapor barrier to the inside of the building. I want to make sure I do it right. Thank you. DAVID in OKLAHOMA CITY
DEAR DAVID: If you are dead set on using this Silvercote insulation then you should cut out any foil radiant barrier. You never want to have a double vapor barrier situation as any trapped moisture will have no method of escaping. Downside of this is you do not have a Weather Resistant Barrier (aka housewrap) between framing and siding. An option to consider would be to resell your metal building insulation, then use unfaced Rockwool batt insulation, as it is unaffected by moisture.
DEAR POLE BARN GURU: I plan to build a 28×48 metal pole barn, concrete floor, 12′ eave with 8/12 pitch. Barn will have 6 3×4 windows, and two 10×10 roll doors, one roll door on each gable end. For now, the roof will be insulated with 3in closed cell foam. I plan to insulate the walls down the road with rigid foam board. The building will not have A/C. Question: Do I need vents or exhaust fan in the gable ends of the roof with the high heat/humidity of Alabama? There will be no ridge vent or soffit vents. I may not have the building open every day, either. Thank you. JASON in MONTGOMERY
DEAR JASON: While placing permanent vents might alleviate your possible mold/mildew/condensation issues, they will defeat your insulation investment. In reality, you should look to a qualified local HVAC provider to provide mechanical dehumidification, else you will have regrets forever. Make sure to have a vapor barrier under your concrete floor, to help reduce interior moisture gain.
DEAR POLE BARN GURU: FROST HEAVE, 44′ deep by 64 long pole barn 20 ceiling height, Tenant build, will be insulated but NO HVAC initially. However, is some type of concrete frost wall (downturn?) via monolithic slab required? Dimensions? MIKE in CINCINNATI
DEAR MIKE: Your slab on grade can be poured to a consistent thickness throughout and all you need to do is properly insulate your slab edge to meet IECC (International Energy Conservation Code) requirements.
DEAR POLE BARN GURU: I’m building a barndominium in Iowa and I wonder if I can do a monolithic slab in a freezing area where the typical frost footing is 42″? Thank you. DAVID in KALONA
DEAR POLE BARN GURU: I’m looking at a pole barn design that I’d like to do, but I’m considering 10′ OC or 9′ OC post spacing rather than 8′ I’ve run the numbers for the roof and the posts, but I wanted to know if the wall girts could handle that span? Looking at 2×6 girts, any advice on how to make sure they stayed within reasonable deflection limits? Also this pole barn has interior walls, as it’s a “barndominium” so we’re looking at doing residential grade, pulling permits etc. on this project. ALAN in ST. GEORGE
DEAR POLE BARN GURU: How much does it cost to get a pole barn one car garage with living quarters above fully finished out on my own property. JENNIFER in GRANDVIEW
DEAR MICHAEL: A caution – if your shed roof ties in at any height other than exactly at eave, or is not at same slope as existing roof, you have a snow slide off/drift load to contend with and are best to engage an engineer to account for this extra loading. An exception would be if you have a snow retention system on your existing roof. Assuming above is not an issue, please read on. As I do not know your loads, you can fill in blanks in this formula to find out: (roof live load + roof dead load) x spacing (in your instance 96″) x span in feet squared (14′ squared for you). Divide this answer by: 8 x Rafter Section Modulus x Fb (fiberstress in bending of lumber proposed to be used) x 1.15 (duration of load for snow) If your result is 1.0 or less, then you are golden. Section Modulus is depth of member squared x width of member divided by 6 Example : 2×12 = 11.25″^2 x 1.5″ / 6 = 31.64 Fb for #2 grade Southern Pine will be 2×8 = 925; 2×10 = 800; 2×12 = 750
DEAR GLEN: Maybe, provided your existing building footings are adequate to support weight you will be adding. Easiest and safest way is to set a row of columns directly alongside existing building wall, so you can treat new structure as being self-supporting. You will not have to pour a foundation, you can auger holes, place UC-4B pressure treated columns in holes, then backfill bottom 16-18″ with premix concrete to create a bottom collar. If your new lean-to has a pitch break, or is lower than main roof on high side, you do need to account for weight of slide off/drifting snow onto it. This can be avoided, by installing a snow retention system on your existing roof.
DEAR POLE BARN GURU: What is the difference between a pole barn home and a barndominium? SHARON in WESTCLIFFE
DEAR SHANE: Provided you have available space, you might want to consider a 36′ x 48′ main building, as it is more efficient in materials usage and will likely be roughly same in investment. Yes, you can have an open floor plan, with no inside walls between main building and lean-to areas. While it is possible to use opaque white translucent polycarbonate panels for portions of roofs, they can prove to be problematic. From a structural aspect, polycarbonate will not adequately transfer wind shear loads, so those area will require steel strapping between roof purlins and sheathing. Below this area, everything will seriously bake – including supporting lumber. All of this lumber (below polycarbonate roofed areas) should be pressure preservative treated to reduce potential incidence of decay.
DEAR POLE BARN GURU:
DEAR POLE BARN GURU: I am working with Jackson on a quote for a 40x60x16 pole barn. The plan was to install the barn on a monolithic slab as our soil up here in Rhode Island is rather rocky. My town building inspector informed me that I would need to submit an engineering/stamped plan for my concrete work. Jackson suggested I reach out to you to discuss if there are any alternatives to a monolithic slab and what your recommendations would be. ALEX in WEST GREENWICH
Kevin is now experiencing joys associated with buildings sold ‘on the cheap’ – with barely enough materials to get a roof on with a minimal budget. It would have been so simple for this building to have been originally sold and erected with provisions to control roof condensation. Either a Reflective Radiant Barrier (RRB) or an Integral Condensation Control (ICC) would have easily avoided your current situation.
Foam board might be a solution, however you would need to have each panel 100% air sealed between purlins in order to do so. Chances of success range close to zero. You are left with two choices – remove roof steel, install a RRB and reinstall roofing or two inches of closed cell spray foam (roughly $5700). Hopefully you have poured your slab on grade over a well-sealed vapor ba